RH Reality Check
Font Size: A |  A |  A

Republicans Running From Far-Right "Pro-Life" Culture Warriors

Scott Swenson's picture

The election is far from over, but if you watch what is happening in the Republican Party right now, it sure seems like the most extreme fringe of the anti-choice right wing must either put up or shut up on election day. It's not the Democrats who are saying that, it's Republicans who are saying it. Loudly. Clearly. With conviction. 

Just today, CC Goldwater, granddaughter of Mr. Conservative, Sen. Barry Goldwater, said it this way:

My grandfather (Paka) would never suggest denying a woman's right to choose. My grandmother co-founded Planned Parenthood in Arizona in the 1930's, a cause my grandfather supported. I'm not sure about how he would feel about marriage rights based on same-sex orientation. I think he would feel that love and respect for one's privacy is what matters most and not the intolerance and poor judgment displayed by McCain over the years. Paka respected our civil liberties and passed on the message that that we should conduct our lives standing up for the basic freedoms we hold so dear.

For a while, there were several candidates who aligned themselves with the Goldwater version of Conservative thought. My grandfather had undying respect for the U.S. Constitution, and an understanding of its true meanings.

There always have been a glimmer of hope that someday, someone would "race through the gate" full steam in Goldwater style. Unfortunately, this hasn't happened, and the Republican brand has been tarnished in a shameless effort to gain votes and appeal to the lowest emotion, fear. Nothing about McCain, except for maybe a uniform, compares to the same ideology of what Goldwater stood for as a politician. The McCain/Palin plan is to appear diverse and inclusive, using women and minorities to push an agenda that makes us all financially vulnerable, fearful, and less safe.

 

Also today, former Republican Governor of Minnesota, Arne Carlson, endorsed Obama and took a shot at his fellow Republican Congresswoman from Minnesota, the far-right anti-choice Rep. Michele Bachmann. According to the AP:

Carlson, who served from 1991 to 1998, also cited recent comments by GOP Congresswoman Michele Bachmann questioning whether politicians have "pro-America or anti-America views." "Regardless of our party, regardless of our partisan inclinations, there is no interest more compelling than the interest in the well-being of the United States..."

 

Susan Eisenhower, daughter for former president, Gen. Dwight David Eisenhower, has long been an Obama supporter.  Last Sunday, Gen. Colin Powell came out for Obama with statements that also referenced Bachmann and the far-right extremists that have controlled the GOP for a generation, and expressed his concern about a Supreme Court that would tilt too far to the right.

Barry Goldwater was a man of Arizona, humble, rough-and-tumble, honest. Eisenhower came from Abeline, Kansas, about as small a town as you can get, with those values Republicans love to talk about. Colin Powell  overcame racism and the Jim Crow south to rise to the highest ranks serving his nation. Arne Carlson represents a plain spoken humility of good governance the upper Midwest is known for.

These are famous names because of the good works they have done. They are not people who had anything handed to them, they cannot be dismissed as "elites."

These are good people, from good families, "real Americans" who are very "pro-America" because they understand freedom, and they see very real threats to it.

Add to these well known names, others like Doug Kmiec, Nicholas Cafardi, and many other conservative pro-life Catholic Republicans specifically speaking up to say it is time to change the debate about abortion.  Surely somewhere, people on the extreme right of the anti-choice movement have turned around to realize no one is following them off the cliff any more.

What is most fascinating is that the threats to America these Republicans see comes from within their own party, from an anti-choice far-right extremism that has gone too far trying to infringe on the personal freedoms of their fellow Americans.

If the far-right anti-choicers can win this election for McCain-Palin, these Republicans endorsing Obama may need to find a new home. If the far-right loses this election for McCain, the Republican Party will be fascinating to watch as devolves into blame, finger pointing, and hopefully public hearings to determine who is a "real Republican" and who is very "pro-Republican." 


. . . . .
4 comments

Don't forget that 43 percent of Democrats take a pro-life position on abortion. Your quoting a handful of Republicans does NOT mean that they are running from the pro-life community. That's a nice fallacy of composition argument and unture.

Kmiec and company's own pro-life credentials are questionable.

Submitted by Steve Ertelt on October 23, 2008 - 9:31pm.

"That's a nice fallacy of composition argument and unture."

It seems to me that someone claiming that 43% of Democrats share your obsession with overturning Roe and forcing women to carry to term against their will and then not providing even a cite for such a ridiculous claim is the LAST person to be talking smack about fallacies, poorly made arguments and most especially, truth.
I am so pleased to have lived long enough to watch the destruction of the religious right and the republican party.

Submitted by colleen on October 23, 2008 - 10:26pm.

Steve - There is a big difference between disagreeing with abortion and disagreeing with the right to choose. Many democrats would say that they are against abortions, but if you asked those same people whether they think its right to take away a woman's own, private, choice in the matter, they would say that is equally wrong. So wherever your 43% statistic is coming from, I highly doubt it is proof of what you are suggesting.

If religious folks are really serious about ending abortion, then they need to throw their (admittedly very influential) support behind things like paid family leave, living wages, affordable child care, and access for working moms to health care services. All of these things would go a much longer way toward reducing abortions than calling people baby-killers and trying to make personal healthcare decisions the jurisdiction of the federal government.

Submitted by shauna on October 26, 2008 - 2:52am.

I agree. When Betty Ford stated she was pro-choice the morons in the republican party were worried that Jerry's approval ratings would take a hit. The opposite happened. That was over 30 years ago.

abortion is a choice that folks need to make within their own family, and within their chosen faith. It has nothing whatsoever to do with politics.

conservative should mean fiscally conservative. forcing ones religious beliefs onto someone else via a government is the opposite of conservative; that stinks of big government.

Dickhead Cheney, said deficits do not matter. This came from a conservative? They consider him ultra conservative! Obviously, that play book has only chapters on social issues.

My suggestions...
1) Stand up and say.. we dont give a crap about abortion. That is no longer a political issue. they removes the ability for democrats to play it against you. it is no longer an "issue". Now run on the real issues.

2) state that you we are going to get a bright light out and show the citizens how senators are pissing away money on pork legislation. refuse to sign any bill that has pork, and state that you will go on prime time tv announcing any senator (rep or democrat) that trys to attach useless crap to a bill.

3) I agree with bushes tax cuts. fine give everyone a 3% break. BUT put back the top tax bracket that they seem to forget telling us that eliminated.

4) Admit that Bush hosed up, lied, etc about Iraq. Re-instate the Powell doctrine (write Palin a note explaining it if necessary). Explain we cannot leave Iraq unstable, but we will get out ASAP.

If McCain had done this, considering his track record, he could have won.

Submitted by JP on November 5, 2008 - 1:28am.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <i> <center> <strike> <del> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <p> <h2> <br> <img> <blockquote>
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Glossary terms will be automatically marked with links to their descriptions.

More information about formatting options