New Mexico Attorney General: Proposed 20-Week Abortion Ban ‘Unconstitutional and Unenforceable’


A proposed ban on abortion after 20 weeks in Albuquerque, New Mexico, would be “unconstitutional and unenforceable,” the state’s attorney general said Wednesday in a letter to a city council member.

Attorney General Gary King, a Democrat, said that “recent federal court actions have struck down ordinances identical or similar to the proposed measure in Albuquerque,” citing a Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals decision that struck down a comparable ban on abortions in Utah, “because it unconstitutionally established viability at 20 weeks.”

Anti-choice activists began campaigning against abortion in the city three years ago, when nationwide anti-choice group Operation Rescue sent two “missionaries” there to garner support for a city petition. The group did gather the more than 12,000 signatures required to push a proposed 20-week abortion ban to a city-wide vote, scheduled to take place November 19.

A ban on abortion after 20 weeks in the city could significantly affect patients at Albuquerque’s Southwestern Women’s Options clinic, one of the few abortion providers in the United States that performs later abortions.

According to the Albuquerque Journal, city councillor Trudy Jones is expected Wednesday night to propose an “action to get a court to determine whether the ordinance is constitutional and whether the city is obligated to hold an election on it,” which the anti-choice Life Legal Defense Foundation called ”an unconstitutional fiat by the City Council and a blatant violation of the powers reserved to the people under the Albuquerque City Charter.”

The American Civil Liberties Union of New Mexico has said it intends to pursue litigation against the ban if it is passed after the November vote.

In a press release, King said, “Voters have the right to know and decide whether they want to bear the protracted expense of litigation over a measure that is unconstitutional and unenforceable.”

Like this story? Your $10 tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

Follow Andrea Grimes on twitter: @andreagrimes

  • fiona64

    The thing that’s asinine about this whole “20 weeks = viability” thing is that a fetus delivered at 20 weeks’ gestation has ZERO possibility of surviving.

    And that’s aside from the fact that a great many fetal anomalies cannot even be *detected* earlier than 20 weeks’ gestation.

    So very sick and tired of politicians practicing medicine without a license! Good on the New Mexico AG!