Anti-Choicers Trying to Drum Up Anti-Girl Scout Sentiment Again


The anti-choice movement’s expanding suspicion that the entire world is out to get it has grown to a point where anti-choicers are warning parents to avoid the Girl Scouts. While most of us think of the Girl Scouts as a wholesome organization devoted to building up girls’ skills and self-esteem, the anti-choice movement has taken to insinuating that your daughter is going to get a badge in “abortion orgies” if she joins up. (In all honesty, the “building up girls’ skills and self-esteem” is likely what’s really bothering the right in these days of panicking about women and girls excelling in school in record numbers. But as with religious fundamentalists around the world, fear of sex is grafted onto every excuse to attack the rights of women and girls to education and employment.)

Now there’s a new website to help conservative parents seeking to know more about how local chapters are connected to pro-choice organizations called My Girl Scout Council.

The mainstream anti-choice movement knows that it can’t reveal its true agenda—trying to reverse women’s march towards equality by using forced childbirth and sexual shame as weapons—too boldly, so the official line on why their followers are supposed to hate the Girl Scouts is the disingenuous claim that abortion is “murder.” Are the Girl Scouts aborting any pregnancies? No. Giving money to terminate pregnancies? No. Taking a stand on the issue of legal abortion? Nope. But, as usual with anti-choicers, there’s no stretch too far. Take LifeSiteNews’ coverage of this new website. The coverage opens with, “The pro-life movement has been concerned for a number of years about the ties between the Girl Scouts and the Planned Parenthood abortion business.”

There are three solid attempts to deceive in that sentence (for people who claim to have the moral high ground, anti-choicers sure do lie a lot!). One, the “ties” between Planned Parenthood and the Girl Scouts are mostly a figment of paranoid right-wing imagination, and include trying to hold the entire Girl Scout organization responsible because one group had a meeting in a room that had previously been used by an HIV prevention group that had accidentally left a pamphlet behind. (Yes, they’re that desperate.) Individual troops may reach out to Planned Parenthood, but the larger organization doesn’t have these “ties.” Two, the claim that Planned Parenthood is an “abortion business,” as if abortion is the bulk of their work, when it only constitutes 3 percent of their services. And three, the claim that Planned Parenthood is a “business,” when it is a nonprofit.

Despite the attempts to deceive right up top, the quote from Ann Saladin, the woman who started My Girl Scout Council, makes it clear that this isn’t about “life,” but about a fear of female sexuality—which is in and of itself a cover story for fearing female independence.

“I wish a resource like this had been available when I was first contemplating my own daughter’s Girl Scout membership,” Saladin explained to LifeSiteNews. “I had no idea that her membership, and the financial contributions solicited through her council, were supporting the international scouting organization, WAGGGS, which aggressively pushes for sexual and reproductive health and rights for girls around the world while representing its 10 million members.”

They fight for the health and rights of the girls they claim to represent. How horrible. Well, if you don’t think girls deserve health and rights it is.

Going to the website itself confirms that Saladin’s main concern isn’t some kind of misplaced fear that embryos are the same thing as children, but that girls who join the Girl Scouts might inadvertently pick up the belief that they are whole human beings who own their own bodies and deserve full human rights. While the site purports to have information about each individual troop, every individual troop link goes to the same document, with the only modification being that Saladin copy and pasted the troop’s name into the headline and first paragraph.

Even if you oppose legal abortion, the attempts to prove that the Girl Scouts has a secret pro-choice agenda are laughably inept—mostly attempts to create guilt by association, including claiming that Girl Scouts should never link an article about any topic if it’s been published in any publication that has published abortion-supportive articles. It’s clear that “abortion” is just a scare word sprinkled throughout to drive up fears that Girl Scouts might have a viewpoint that comes anywhere close to the belief that women might have a greater role on earth than being helpmeets for husbands.

Saladin is concerned that Girl Scouts USA (GSUSA) is part of the World Association of Girl Guides and Girl Scouts (WAGGGS), and because some of the groups around the world are more aggressively progressive than GSUSA, there’s supposedly guilt by association. GSUSA also has associations with organizations and individuals who believe women are full human beings and may even call themselves feminists. Shocking, I know. Why would an organization that’s supposed to be “for girls” actually produce programs promoting the well-being of girls?

Saladin is extremely irritated, for instance, that GSUSA participates in World Thinking Day, a day set aside by WAGGGS in order to promote the education of girls around the world. Saladin, at least, knows better than to just complain about the promotion of girls’ education, so instead she tries to create a chain of guilt by association that is pretty hard to follow: WAGGGS has done work with groups that promote the rights of youth around the world. Those rights include the right to sexual health care, including safe abortion access, and comprehensive sex education. Therefore, by participating in an event promoting education by a group that has worked with other groups that promote sexual health, GSUSA has “sexual health” cooties. Voila! You can’t support girls’ education without sex and abortion. Yes, it’s exhausting. I suspect it’s meant to be: The hope is by piling on a bunch of nonsensical guilt-by-association sex panic arguments, the reader won’t notice that Saladin’s trying to drum up outrage that scouts are being taught to respect the importance of getting an education.

The same strategy is used throughout the document: Thin guilt-by-association sex panic arguments that are confusing and whose only purpose seems to be overwhelming the reader into not realizing that the Girl Scouts is really “guilty” of promoting girls’ education, women’s history, and the idea that women have things to contribute besides just being wives and mothers. It seems by attempting to delude readers into thinking that the Girl Scouts has a “secret” agenda, Saladin has accidentally revealed that it’s the anti-choice movement who, in reality, has a poorly kept secret: That they are more opposed to women’s rights than they are supportive of fetal life.

Like this story? Your $10 tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

Follow Amanda Marcotte on twitter: @amandamarcotte

  • John H

    “I wish a resource like this had been available when I was first
    contemplating my own daughter’s Girl Scout membership,” Saladin
    explained to LifeSiteNews. “I had no idea that her membership, and the
    financial contributions solicited through her council, were supporting
    the international scouting organization, WAGGGS, which aggressively
    pushes for sexual and reproductive health and rights for girls around
    the world while representing its 10 million members.”

    Wow. How dare they support the sexual and reproductive health and rights of girls and young women…? This really might be the clearest statement of hostility toward women’s well-beings Ive seen from an anti-choicer; they usually know to hide it better.

    • Mea River

      I had to read the article twice, because I got to that paragraph and it sounded like Saladin was in support of the Girl Scouts and I got confused. I mean, she used the phrase “sexual and reproductive health and rights.” “RIGHTS.” Who the hell calls them “rights” when they’re opposed to them? A better question would be, who opposes something that they acknowledge is a right?

      Insane troll logic at it’s finest, I suppose

  • fiona64

    These anti-choice nitwits must be great yogis/yoginis, with some of the stretches they make …

    And yes, Heaven forfend that a young woman grow up with the idea that she is a whole person. How dreadful.

  • PictishMonster

    Thank you, Amanda, for explicitly making the link between fear of women’s sexuality and fear of women’s independence. That connection is often glossed over, perhaps because on one level it seems self-evident. But stating it brings the truth out into the open. It should be spelled out again and again.

    • Valde

      It’s always been about female independence – they just can’t come right out and say it.

      Abortion and contraception are all dogwhistles for their desire to see women back in the home, ChristianSHARIAH style

  • Beyond_Reason

    Cookies are the only girl scout agenda.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Amorette-Allison/1163340223 Amorette Allison

    I was also a Scout and a leader for many years and we never discussed abortion, even when I was the leader of a troop of senior girls. I remember attending some leadership training where they talked about peer pressure driving girls to smoke and do drugs and have sex but the only people there were leaders. Most of them mothers. Which made me suspect they had given into peer pressure and had sex.

  • Lin Chan

    YOU’RE SO FUNNY. First you complain that Pro-life people don’t have facts to back them up, then you go on to list some of the very facts that bolster they are telling Truth! How awful it must be to have to always purposely obfuscate in order to maintain your Liberal Progressive goals to protect pro-abortion advocates like Girl Scouts… “One, the ‘ties’ between Planned Parenthood and the Girl Scouts are mostly a figment of paranoid right-wing imagination,
    and include trying to hold the entire Girl Scout organization
    responsible… [you know as well as I that Girl Scouts of the USA is THE SINGLE LARGEST FUNDING (and FOUNDING) associate of WAGGGS, and without American Girl Scouts cookie profits and Thinking Day donations, WAGGGS would be grounded in London instead of jetsetting off to Bali and Kuala Lumpur to push explicit-sex-ed-with-abortion-promotion on developing countries, or you wouldn't be running to GSUSA's rescue]… “Two, the claim that Planned Parenthood is an ‘abortion business,’ as if abortion is the bulk of their work, when it
    only constitutes 3 percent of their services”… [abortion is TRULY 36.7% of PP's "REVENUE" (that's OVER 1/3) and abortion "SERVICES" are TRULY 10% of those listed]… “And three, the claim that Planned Parenthood is a ‘business,’ when it is a nonprofit”… [Honey, you are smoking way too much if you think they run their nonprofit without dumping all the excess cash into the retirement/investment account at the end of the fiscal year to pay off executive bonuses the following year... just like Girl Scouts of the USA.] GSUSA and PPFA Birds of a feather with a flock-mate like you shows the Pro-Life community is right on-target; you rush to defend Girl Scouts without realizing support from someone like YOU, with your rabidly pro-slut and “choose”-to-kill-babies attitude only galvanizes the argument!

  • Judith Ann Simons Gorsky

    You can not be serious????