Dr. Leroy Carhart is closing his Nebraska clinic, which the anti-choice movement declares to be a victory. But is it really a victory when he’s opening up three new clinics instead?
Via the Washington Post:
A Nebraska doctor who is one of few in the U.S. performing late-term abortions said Wednesday he wants to ensure more women have access to the procedure by expanding to states where it remains legal.
Dr. LeRoy Carhart said he wants to open new clinics near Washington D.C. and in Council Bluffs, Iowa, while expanding operations at his existing clinic in Bellevue, Neb. and at a clinic in Indianapolis to offer other reproductive medical treatments. Late-term abortions would be offered at the clinics in the Washington D.C. area and Council Bluffs, he said.
“There’s certainly a need, and these areas are where the laws are favorable for us to do the practice that I need to do,” Carhart said Wednesday in an interview with The Associated Press.
The anti-choice activists are downplaying the fact that their push to oust Carhart in Nebraska is simply moving him about 20 miles down the road, as well as encouraging him to open additional locations.
Carhart says he plans to have three new abortion facilities up and running by January with one in the Maryland-D.C. area, and another in Council Bluffs, Iowa offering late-term abortions. He also is acquiring an Indianapolis abortion clinic, which specializes only in early-term abortions.
He said that the reason for moving his late-term abortion business out of Bellvue is Nebraska’s new abortion ban, Legislative Bill 1103. The law prohibits elective abortions after 20 weeks post-conception on the basis that science definitively shows an unborn child feels pain at that age. That standard effectively prohibits Carhart from performing late-term abortions, which provide the bulk of his business.
“This sort of forced us. We had to do it,” Carhart told the Omaha World Herald. “In Iowa and Maryland, we can do the later cases.”
The abortionist plans to coordinate with his lawyers on filing a constitutional challenge against LB 1103, as he moves his business to the new locations.
Julie Schmit-Albin, executive director of Nebraska Right to Life, told the World Herald that Carhart’s decision to move out of state “shows that LB 1103 was the right strategy.”
The anti-abortion groups behind the “Fetal Pain” act now admit that their main goal was to get a challenge to the bill that might get them in front of the Supreme Court. Since that didn’t happen, now they are claiming moving Carhart is just as big of a victory.
The genius behind the legislation was the thinking that it would be challenged in court and the pro-life movement could win a favorable decision from the high court on the heels of the ruling upholding the national partial-birth abortion ban.
Mary Balch, the state legislative director for the National Right to Life Committee, said at the time that she hoped it would cause a national discussion on the pain unborn children feel because it draws attention to their humanity and need for legal protection.
Also, she hoped the Pain Capable Unborn Child Protection Act could see the same group of five members of the Supreme Court who backed the partial-birth abortion ban uphold it as constitutional and allow more abortions to be prohibited.
But, with the news that the late-term abortion practitioner LeRoy Carhart is possibly relocating to another state and him saying the fetal pain bill is responsible, Balch says the further genius of the bill is seen.
“This announcement illustrates the importance of having states pass protective laws such as the one passed in Nebraska,” she told LifeNews.com this afternoon. “Now is the time for Right to Lifers to capitalize on the dramatic pro-life gains in state legislative and gubernatorial elections last week and to make it illegal to kill unborn children who are capable of feeling pain.”
“As a result of last week’s elections, the number of states where pro-life legislation stands a realistic chance of enactment has substantially increased,” the pro-life attorney added.
With a number of state legislatures moving to complete GOP control, copy cat legislation can be expected to pop up all over in the next session. The idea that this type of onerous, controversial bill could be held to one state is no longer a given, and a court challenge is likely to be the only way to avoid a country that will allow women the right to an abortion after 20 weeks only if she is lucky enough to live in a certain state.
Mini Roundup: Maybe abortion doesn’t cause mental health issues for every woman, but the public still believes every woman should at the very least be ashamed. And if you aren’t, you’re just “hiding” from it.
November 11, 2010
- 29% of pregnant women in SA are HIV positive – Times LIVE
- Cervical cancer vaccinations for schoolgirls – Yellow Advertiser
- Mobile phone messages improve adherence and HIV control in Kenyan trial15 … – Aidsmap
- Philippine legislators make new push for family planning despite Catholic … – The Canadian Press
- Philippine lawmakers to push family planning bill – Washington Post
- Smoking ban leads to major decrease in maternal smoking, pre-term births – Sify
- Bolivia Promotes Sex Education To Prevent Diseases – Bernama
- Breaking the silence on unsafe abortion – Forum addresses broken promises on … – ReliefWeb (press release)
- Palin calls for repeal of health law, says it will increase abortions – Dallas Morning News
- Namibia: Abortion Ban Risks Women’s Lives – AllAfrica.com
- Perry Calls Dropping Medicaid “Good Idea” – KERA
- Malaysia to introduce sex education – Independent Online
- Malaysia to teach safe sex in schools next year – Philippine Star
- ‘Woman of the Year’ helps cancer victims – Great Bend Tribune
- Birth control could soon be free to insured women under new health care amendment – The Daily Tar Heel
- Small things made huge difference in Toomey-Sestak race – Main Line
- Texting leads to touchingâ€¦ – London Free Press (blog)
- Malaysian schools to introduce sex education – Bangkok Post
- Teens ‘more open’ to sexual diversity – ABC Online
- Kenya Launches Maternal Health Campaign – SOS Children’s Villages Canada
November 10, 2010
- Africa: Pepfar Showing Greater Effectiveness, Efficiency Against HIV/Aids – AllAfrica.com
- Unprotected first sex more likely among females, student finds – Web Devil
- Tifatul defends shaking hands with Michele Obama – Jakarta Post
- LGBTs express disappointment with Pelosi’s speakership – Bay Area Reporter
- The FDA approves Egrifta, the first drug to treat HIV patients with lipodystrophy – Los Angeles Times
- Mobile Technology May Alter Estimates of Maternal and Infant Mortality – Medscape
- Neb. abortion doctor to practice where laws permit – Washington Post
- Mobile phone messages improve adherence and HIV control in Kenyan trial7 hours ago – Aidsmap
- Malaysia to introduce sex education next year in schools – Monsters and Critics.com
- Republican pro-lifers in, Democratic pro-lifers out: It’s not a religious thing – The Upshot
- State budget feelng the pinch with end of federal dollars – The Colorado Statesman
- Promises to protect women from unsafe abortions must be kept – Media For Freedom
- Abortion’s mental health debate – Washington Post
- Aging population could bring vital changes to family planning policy – People’s Daily Online
- Fetal Pain Law Hailed as Successful, Making Abortion Practitioner Leave State – LifeNews.com
- Programs offer free, affordable health care for local children – Canon City Daily Record
- Group mobilises youths against female genital mutilation – Nigerian Compass (blog)
- Kids, A Joint Is Not A Condom – The Atlantic
- Birth control pills may have caused 30-year-old’s stroke – USA Today
- Rhode Island Governor-Elect appoints Illegal Abortionist to Transition Team – Lifesite
- Neb. Abortionist to Open Clinics in Iowa, Md., Ind. – Christian Post
- HHS to help push ‘text4baby’ service to 1 million – FCW.com
- Ruth Rosen: What Obama could learn from social movements… – TPMCafé
- John DiStaso’s Granite Status: Ayotte joins Senate GOP call for a Balanced … – The Union Leader
- Study: big women have risky sex – Creative Loafing Tampa (blog)
- First New Scottish Order of Nuns in 150 Years Devoted to Promoting Culture of Life – Lifesite
- Communication is best birth control method – Herald Palladium (subscription)
- Media Take Pro-Abortion Side on Twitter #ihadanabortion Topic – LifeNews.com
- Couple fights for 2nd child – Shanghai Daily
- Anti-abortion pastor Rev. Philip ‘Flip’ Benham wrong, on all counts – Creative Loafing (blog)
- Doctor opening new late-abortion clinics in DC area, Iowa – Washington Post
- Unconventional Idea for Antiviral Contraceptive Gel Wins Gates Foundation Grant – Nanotechnology and Development News
- Teen Girls More Likely to Have Unprotected Sex Their First Time – ParentDish
- Real truth about Gloucester 18′s ‘Pregnancy Pact’ – newjerseynewsroom.com
- Abortion Foes Pick Up Seats In Mass. House – WCVB-TV
- Abortion should carry a stigma – New York Post (blog)
- Catholics set massive show of force – Malaya
- Good, clean fun in the bedroom: Condoms, safe words, consensual, adventure, spice – Eagle News
- AIDS Project fights stigma of being HIV-positive – Centre Daily Times
- Your morning jolt: Can women stop Democratic bleeding? – Atlanta Journal Constitution (blog)
- Cervical smear test – ITV.com
- Class focus runs beyond abstinence, EVSC says – Evansville Courier & Press
- Another Year Could Bring License-Plate Battles – Sun Gazette
- WWHI Introduces Low Cost Wireless Device for Fetal and Maternal Monitoring – TMCnet
- Man in Ohio accused of damaging church’s anti-abortion display, police say he … – Fox 59
- Study: Most Teenage Girls Skip HPV Vaccine – WGCL Atlanta
- Conservative Belgian archbishop in eye of storm – The Associated Press
- Calling all cancer advocates! Rally in Annapolis! – Examiner.com
- Neb. abortion doc plans clinics in 3 more states – Chicago Tribune
- Leeds mother calls for lower cancer screening age – BBC News
- Column: Title V has been improving health of Ohio’s women, children for 75 years – Zanesville Times Recorder
- Even after 8 decades, old arguments about family planning persist – Minnesota Public Radio
- Shock Bay teenage pregnancy rates – Weekend Post
- RH advocates back websites on sex ed for teens – GMANews.TV
- NJ Dems Continue Efforts To Restore Family Planning Funding, Expand Access To … – Medical News Today (press release)
- Aging Population May Bring Changes to Family Planning Policy – CRIENGLISH.com
- Birth control gels well – iAfrica.com
- Risky sex linked to weight – Yale Daily News
- Cervical cancer scandal: tests ‘misread’ – Channel 4 News
- Death of Jade Goody from cervical cancer credited with brief increase in smear … – Telegraph.co.uk
- Aquino to meet bishops anew on birth control – Manila Standard Today
- Good, clean fun in the bedroom: Condoms, safe words, consensual, adventure, spice – Eagle News
- LGBT issues at UW – UW Badger Herald
- Are men not allowed to offer opinions about abortion? – Washington Times