Hypocrisy Watch: Yet Another Legislator of Morality to Resign Over Affair with Staffer (UPDATED)

6:56 pm: Please note that the video embedded below, originally showing Congressman Souder being interviewed by Tracy Jackson (his aide and the woman with whom he had an affair) has been removed from YouTube by Cong Souder’s office.  The subject was Cong. Souder’s deep belief in abstinence from sex outside of marriage.

9:07 pm: Thanks to a reader and a new link, the video is back.

Yet another in a lengthening line of legislative moralizers will resign today as a result of his own hypocrisy.

Today’s example is Congressman Mark Souder (R-IN), who has spent his time in Congress telling everyone else what is right from wrong and how to live their lives according to his definition of morality. 

He is resigning due to an affair with a female staffer.  He said in a statement that he “sinned against God, my wife and my family by having a mutual relationship with a part-time member of my staff.”

A few tidbits about Souder:

He has voted for school prayer, but against funding schools, especially for minority students.  He is rated as “anti-public education” by the National Education Association.

In June 2009, he voted against providing four weeks of paid parental leave for federal employees, and for this and other similar votes is rated as having a 100% “pro-family” voting record by the Christian Coalition.  (Clearly, definitions of “pro-family” may vary.)

He voted against expanding the Children’s Health Insurance Program in January 2009 and also against expanding SCHIP to cover 6 million more children in 2008 and against adding 2 to 4 million more children to SCHIP in 2007.  He voted in favor of denying non-emergency treatment to patients for lack of Medicare co-pay. (Feb 2006)

He voted against raising the minimum wage in 2007, and for limiting welfare payments to 2 years, while voting against support for low-income housing.

(Gotta love those family values).

And he is of course completely anti-choice, with a 0 percent rating from NARAL Pro-Choice America, and a 100 percent rating from the National Right to Life Committee.

He has a solid record voting against the health and rights of gay, lesbian, and transgender persons.

He is, of course, (of course!!!) a strong proponent of abstinence-only education and against condoms….(hopefully though, not during his own sexual pecadillos).

Future Answer for Trivial Pursuit: Tracy Jackson, the woman interviewing Souder in the above video on his strong position on abstinence-only programs is in fact the woman with whom he had the affair. Let’s just say he’s a multitasker.

He is also a fundamentalist Christian who believes that the Bible is “the inerrant, perfect, revealed Word of God and is our number-one guidebook” for politics and policy.

And of course, he believes in compassion and all that other stuff.  Just not when it comes to the laws he supports.

In short, he believes that what he believes should determine what you believe and how you must act.

But…thankfully for Souder, he also believes in eternal salvation for the sinner, and so despite the clear morality that he has advanced in law to ensure how you live your own life, he knows that having lived as a sinner, he will be forgiven, by God and hopefully by his wife and three children.

And today, he starts that journey by resigning from Congress, cause it’s kinda hard to keep legislating morality when your own sins so obviously diverge from the inerrant, perfect revealed truth by which you think everyone else (except yourself) should live.

But this is rich: He blames his downfall on the “poisonous environment of Washington, D.C., [in which] any personal failing is seized upon, often twisted, for political gain. I am resigning rather than to put my family through that painful, drawn-out process.”

How’s that for personal responsiblity?  I’d say that the “poisonous environment” is the one created by people like Souder in the first place, and that he is being hoisted on his own moral petard.

Like this story? Your $10 tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

For more information or to schedule an interview with contact press@rhrealitycheck.org.

Follow Jodi Jacobson on twitter: @jljacobson

  • sylvie

    Morality and performance of duty are artificial measures that become necessary when something essential is lacking.  The more successfully a person was denied access to his or her feelings in childhood, the larger the arsenal of intellectual weapons and the supply of moral prostheses has to be, because morality and a sense of duty are not sources of strength or fruitful soil for genuine affection.  Blood does not flow in artificial limbs; they are for sale and can serve many masters.” Alice Miller


  • rbpettit

    The video of Souder and his mistress/staffer discussing the virtues of abstinence (for everyone else) may still be accessed at:


    This is the video Souder REALLY wanted you to watch, until this afternoon, when he really DIDN’T want you to watch it anymore, and his office began having it removed from websites. I find it much more interesting and revealing now, don’t you?

  • crowepps

    Traditional as in one (cheating) man and one woman (whose religion tells her the cheating has to be forgiven.


    Personally, I prefer a modern marriage, where if the man does any traditional cheating the woman gets to move out and take half the assets with her.

  • ahunt

    Snerk…me too.

    For what it is worth, I’ve seen couples rebuild the marriage after infidelity…but I have never seen a marriage survive a wife’s indiscretion.

  • crowepps

    I have seen marriages survive the wife’s indiscretion, although I wouldn’t say the marriages were what I would call healthy.  Of course, my guess is they weren’t particularly healthy BEFORE.  Healthy marriages do not include lying and sneaking around to commit adultery.  Healthy people who no longer emotionally are committed to being married announce that fact and leave the marriage BEFORE they start ‘dating’ others.

  • ahunt

    Ya think?

    Though I’m willing to give the “rebuilt” marriages the benefit of the doubt, the “healthy” condition most certainly came later…

  • deb-r

    I live in Souder’s district–my friends and I are all cheering–yeah!!! Another hypocrite gone–now there is a real chance that Dr Hayhurst will win this election and we can finally have a real family values represetative for NE Indiana. For those of you who live in NE Indiana get out there and support Dr Hayhurst please!!!

    I just love (sarcasm) how these family value conservatives preach abstinence only for everyone else when they can’t control themselves (how do they expect a teenager with raging hormones to say no when they can’t!)