Roundup: On Waivers, Prenatal Care, Personhood and Slavery


Today, it’s follow up time on some of the stories and themes we’ve been following this year across the country.

Remember when Wake County in North Carolina decided it wanted to do away with abortion coverage in its employee insurance plans?  They may get their coverage back now, or at least have a chance to discuss it rather than have it rammed through by one commissioner.

Commissioner Stan Norwalk doesn’t think Cooke should have moved unilaterally. He said Sunday that the board should have voted on whether to drop the coverage.

“I don’t want to be bullied into doing something that we wouldn’t have otherwise done,” Norwalk said.

The Democrat also said fewer than 20 women have had county-funded abortions in the last five years.

“By in large, tax dollars aren’t being used to pay for abortions,” Norwalk said.

In light of the anti-choice claim that women who need abortions can just get a seperate policy to cover that procedure, the Washington Post takes a look at states that provide “abortion riders” for people who have insurance plans that don’t cover abortion.  Surprise!  No one ever purchases them. 

Amid a high-stakes debate over abortion that could determine the fate of President Obama‘s health-care initiative, North Dakota’s law offers a test because it is much like the language favored by antiabortion lawmakers on Capitol Hill, notably Rep. Bart Stupak (D-Mich.).

“There’s not a lot to tell. We have no member who elected to have abortion riders,” said Denise Kolpack, vice president of Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Dakota, which covers about 80 percent of the North Dakota market. “We would be legally bound to provide an offering, but we have no groups that have requested it.”

Similar policies are in place in Kentucky, Missouri, Idaho and Oklahoma.

“It is rare that we hear in the market that an employer would request a rider for this coverage,” said Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield spokesman Tony Felts, whose territory includes Kentucky.

In the five states where abortion coverage is prohibited except with a rider, it is unclear how customers who purchase group insurance, typically for their employees, learn about the abortion coverage option.

“I’m not sure if an employer would know that or not,” Felts said of customers in Kentucky, when asked whether Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield advertises its policies. He said that if a customer requested abortion coverage, the company would offer it “in compliance” with state law.

Blue Cross of Idaho spokesman Stewart Johnson said, “I don’t know that we would mention it. They would probably ask about it.” He said the company does not track how often a group purchases abortion insurance.

A look at Congressman Bart Stupak’s home district in Michigan reveals that there isn’t even an abortion provider there, and that his overreaching amendment would negatively affect what little prenatal care the uninsured in his district can receive.

“Right now abortion is already restricted,” said Julie McKeiver, spokeswoman for Planned Parenthood of Western and Northern Michigan. “[Stupak’s amendment] would take away any reasonable expectation that they would get coverage of services.”

The regional Planned Parenthood organization has been forced by budget cuts to close clinics and reduce hours but maintains clinics that do not perform abortions in Petoskey and Marquette. Women who live in northern lower Michigan or the U.P. often must travel hundreds of miles to downstate abortion providers or cross into Wisconsin or Minnesota for services.

Unfortunately, abortion is not the only medical service not available to women in Stupak’s district without having to travel a long distance. It may be particularly ironic that if Stupak’s abortion concerns end up killing the health care reform bill, pregnant women in his district may lose access to the pre- and post-natal care that is crucial to the health of their babies. Increasing numbers of uninsured residents are putting a huge strain on hospitals and forcing them to close down their obstetrics departments.

According to the most recent data available from the Michigan Department of Community Health, 15.6 percent of Michigan’s non-elderly adults are uninsured, and northern lower Michigan has a higher than average rate of people who are uninsured.

Cheboygan Memorial Hospital closed its urgent care walk-in clinic last month and announced that it will discontinue its obstetric services this month because the high level of uninsured and Medicaid patients has bankrupted the unit. According to the hospital, in fiscal year 2009 CMH posted a $304,000 loss in the OB department.

In a statement the small hospital explained that its main service area includes not only Cheboygan County but also Presque Isle County, Montmorency County, the northern half of Emmet County, and the eastern half of Mackinac County, and that seasonal unemployment levels in some of these areas tops well over 25 percent.

Florida made the news for attempting to make all abortion criminal earlier this year.  Now, as legislation piles up, political experts are noticing the trend of “symbolic politics” as candidates try to cozy up to their anti-choice base.

Creating jobs and cutting spending may be lawmakers’ declared priorities this spring, but that has not dissuaded some conservatives from filing a raft of proposals relating to abortion and the unborn.

About half of the bills come from legislators running for re-election, in a year when Tea Party activists and other GOP malcontents are challenging candidates to prove their conservative credentials. At least one bill was scheduled for a hearing early in the session, by a Republican committee chairwoman who is running for governor.

John Stemberger, of the Florida Family Policy Council, said he’s delighted to see this year’s show of anti-abortion initiatives. Lawmakers’ votes and sponsorship of at least some of the bills, he said, will factor prominently in the guide to political candidates his organization compiles each year for socially conservative voters.

Finally, two weeks ago, Arizona politician Trent Franks stated that abortion was worse for the African American community than slavery.  Now, Personhood Nevada is comparing its drive to get fertilized eggs to have full rights to the push to end slavery in the country.

The initiative petition, filed Oct. 21 with the Secretary of State’s Office, would amend the Nevada Constitution to give “the inalienable right to life for everyone, young or old, health or ill, conscious or unconscious, born or unborn.”

The opening brief filed Thursday, signed by Las Vegas lawyer Michael L. Peters, says the Civil War was fought to correct a “terrible wrong” that blacks were considered property and not people.

This petition, Peters said, seeks a constitutional amendment that every human being from the beginning of life shall be considered a person.

Judge Russell said the language in the initiative petition was too general and vague and failed to give adequate notice to residents of what they would be voting on.

Frankly, I think anyone who believes that a fertilized egg is a “person” should take a moment and ask a couple who have undergone a failed IVF attempt how they enjoy being parents.  That should make it very clear that pregnancy does not begin at fertilization.

Mini Roundup – It’s a very rare occurrence when the pro-choice and anti-choice get to agree.  The Nebraska prenatal funding bill is one of those moments of convergence where everyone gets to be mad at the governor.

March 12, 2010

Anti-abortion campaigner arrested over ‘death threats’ to Elton John – PinkNews.co.uk

Dahlkemper’s health-care reform vote not set – GoErie.com

Pelosi: Stupak Wants Health Care Reform (VIDEO) – Huffington Post

NYT Urges Abortion-Rights Supporters to ‘Make Their Voices Heard.’ The Real … – Newsweek

First thoughts: Trust and the trip – msnbc.com

3 Observations on the Current State of Healthcare Reform -— Counting Votes … – Hospital Review

Survey Shows Closing Gap In Generational Differences Concerning Abortion – RTT News

Bart Stupak: Nancy Pelosi Lacks Votes for Pro-Abortion Health Care in House – LifeNews.com

Michigan: Trucker Guilty in Killings – New York Times

Pelosi Calls Stupak’s Bluff on Abortion – Big Think

Stupak Gains Primary Challenger – Ms. Magazine

Universal health care tends to cut the abortion rate – Washington Post

If Republicans keep ignoring abortion, they’ll lose in the midterm elections – Washington Post

Pro-Life Democrat Claims Committee Chairman Wants Government to Fund Abortions – FOXNews

Advocating for Women: Texas Equal Access Fund. – Tapped

Abortion Tweeter Sets Sparks Flying Across Internet – AOL News

Maddow: Anti-abortion language can’t pass through reconciliation – Raw Story

State verifies signatures for abortion initiative – KTUU

House passes abortion ultrasound bill – Charleston Gazette

Tea Party Avoids Divisive Social Issues – New York Times

Anti-abortion zealot makes pitch to Iowa evangelical voters – Salt Lake Tribune

Pelosi Aborts Stupak Negotiations – TIME

Secretary Clinton Should Raise Issue of China’s One Child Policy in Beijing – Huffington Post

Women on Contraceptive Pills May Live Longer – TopNews United States

Philippine voters would defy church on birth control – AsiaOne

How birth control pills may affect our ability to find a proper mate. – ABC News

Can the Birth Control Pill Help You Live Longer? – TIME

Women on Birth Control Live Longer – Daily Beast

All those births put planet at risk, scholars warn – Salt Lake Tribune

HIV/AIDS Registers a Rise Among Girls and Women – TopNews United States

Nearly 100 Australian authors condemn China for denying visa to HIV-positive … – The Canadian Press

Ugandan Doctor Fears Ground May be Lost Against HIV/AIDS if US and other … – Voice of America

Protect the drug giants’ patents – and harm the health of the poor? – The Guardian

Women Declare: ‘We’re Not Dolls!’ – Brooklyn Daily Eagle

Genital Herpes Hits Black Women Hardest – NPR

March 13, 2010

Specialty plates touting right to abortion will face vote today – The Virginian-Pilot

US avoids anti-abortion debate at UN meeting – The Associated Press

Bart Stupak: Abortion Problem For Democrats – The Admonition

GOP gubernatorial hopefuls clash – San Diego Union Tribune

Georgia Considers Outlawing Abortions Based on Race, Gender – FOXNews

Poizner shifts on abortion and school bonds – San Diego News Room

‘Trust Women/Respect Choice’ License Plate Passes – WJZ

W.Va. abortion bill heads to Gov. Manchin – Charleston Gazette

Catholic hospitals support health care bill – The Associated Press

Emaciated budget trumps sideshow of social bills – R & D Magazine

Dark days when abortion was illegal – Berkshire Eagle

Catholic Health Association Endorses Pro-Abortion Senate Health Care Bill – LifeNews.com

Both candidates veer right in Calif. GOP gov. race – San Jose Mercury News

Insurers report on use of abortion riders – Washington Post

Virginia legislators, give us choices – Daily Press

Lawmakers should show they care by mandating that emergency contraception be … – Plain Dealer

Annie Lennox trying to get world to see changing face of AIDS – CNN International

March 14, 2010

Catholic Health Group Accepts Abortion Language in Reform Bill – Politics Daily

House, Senate bills both change policy, differ on impact – Wausau Daily Herald

Obama’s health care legacy hangs on power of Rep. Clyburn’s persuasion – MiamiHerald.com

Ultrasound bill goes to Manchin – Beckley Register-Herald

Abortion Debate Still Contains More Questions Than Answers – Southern Pines Pilot

Anti-abortion group says amendment push similar to slavery issue – Las Vegas Sun

New Bill On Abortion Practices Passes – WTAP-TV

Health care, Catholics, and life issues – Examiner.com

Debate on abortion will never go away – Yuma Sun

Wake could restore abortion funding from insurance – WRAL.com

Several abortion bills await in Tallahassee – Tampa Tribune

WV Pro-Life Group Pleased With Legislative Action  – WHAG

Obama Administration Pushes Back on Abortion Claims – New York Times

Birth control is an electoral issue, says new survey – Manila Standard Today

Partying to Change the World – New York Times

Floating population births a worry – Global Times

Failure to Act by the Kentucky House of Representatives Leaves Hundreds of … – PR Web

CDC Launches HIV/AIDS Info Web Site – Afro American

Annie Lennox “SINGS”! Asks for Help for Women and Children – Lez Get Real

D.C. handing out 500000 female condoms to fight HIV – CNN

Cabinet approves new anti HIV/AIDS plan – Politicsweb

New female condom adds to anti-AIDS arsenal – Chicago Tribune

HIV/AIDS care needs state funds – Charleston Post Courier

Health-Care Fight Targets Waverers – Wall Street Journal

C-Sections linked to women dying in/after childbirth – Examiner.com

Sarah Tucker: Health care for babies – Omaha World-Herald

Prenatal care debate: Beyond costs – Omaha World-Herald

Local infant mortality higher among blacks than whites – Houma Courier

Give children knowledge of sex – Salt Lake Tribune

March 15, 2010

Life, Rights Begin At Conception – Harrisonburg Daily News Record

Catholics Start to Show Cards on Health Reform – TIME

Arguments Set In Abortion Nofification – MyFox Chicago

Stupak: There Is No Abortion Compromise – TPMDC

Lawmakers claim abortion bills don’t limit rights of women – Tampa Tribune

Oral arguments scheduled in Illinois abortion notification case – FOX2now.com

Free Contraception Can Cut Abortion Rate in Half – eMaxHealth

Count Your Sperms Before You Plan – Oneindia

Plan advocating sterilization continues to spark criticism, debate, support – Honolulu Star-Bulletin

Contraceptive pill use ‘is not linked to a higher death rate’ – Zenopa

Children, women with HIV face destitution & violence – MorungExpress

Panel Questions “VBAC Bans,” Advocates Expanded Delivery Options for Women – Media Newswire

Drop in childbirth deaths not happening – Chicago Daily Herald

DIY cervical cancer test launched today – Mirror.co.uk

Midwife law may deliver more home births – Casper Star-Tribune Online

Like this story? Your $10 tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

Follow Robin Marty on twitter: @robinmarty

  • crowepps

    Current law applies the charge to the killing of a viable fetus, defined in Florida Criminal Code as being “capable of meaningful life outside the womb through standard medical measures.” Courts have generally interpreted that to mean development reached at the end of the second trimester.

     

    Fasano’s bill would expand the charge significantly, to the killing of “a member of the species homo sapiens, at any stage of development, who is carried in the womb.”

     

    The bill was scheduled for a vote last week in the Senate Criminal Justice Committee, but was temporarily postponed when the committee ran short of time to hear it. Committee chairwoman Paula Dockery said she would reschedule the hearing for this week.

     

    Dockery, R-Lakeland, is running for governor and is avowedly pro-life, although some conservatives have challenged that since she refused to support requiring that pregnant women seeking an abortion get an ultrasound. Dockery defends her pro-life credentials, saying the bill was an unwarranted government intrusion into private affairs. She cited similar reasons for not noting voting with other pro-life legislators for mandating life support in the case of brain-damage patient Terri Schiavo, which also angered social conservatives.

     

    Fasano, described himself as “a realist” about abortion rights. “I don’t want anything in the bill that would in anyway hinder a mother’s rights. This is not about abortion … if it violated a mother’s rights, it would be challenged immediately and overturned.”

    And of course I’m sure he doesn’t see how his using the term “moither’s rights” could possibly be offensive to anyone.  After all, they have uteruses, dont’ they?  Doesn’t that mean they’re all SUPPOSED to be mothers?

  • crowepps

    SOME 87 percent of Filipinos will vote for a presidential candidate who advocates a reproductive health program, while 64 percent will elect one who promotes modern methods of family planning, a new survey shows.

     

    The survey, conducted by Pulse Asia, asked 1,800 registered voters about their views on family planning between Feb. 21 and 25. The study was commissioned by the Philippine Legislators’ Committee on Population Development shortly after Catholic bishops attacked Health Secretary Esperanza Cabral for distributing free condoms on Valentine’s Day.

     

    Some 91 percent of the respondents were Catholics who said they disagreed with the Chuch’s position that it is a sin to use contraceptive devices such as pills, condoms and injectables, or to undergo ligation or vasectomy.

     

    Nine of 10 adult Filipinos said the ability to control fertility or plan the family was very important, 2 percent said it was not, and 8 percent were undecided.

     

    Some 75 percent said it was very important or important that family planning be included in a candidate’s program of action, while 6 percent said it was not. Nineteen percent were undecided.

    It would be very interesting to see a survey done in the United States asking similar questions, particularly if the survey avoided linking the question to abortion but instead just focused on birth control.

  • crowepps

    Submitted by Deborah Mitchell on 2010, March 15 – 02:41

     

    When Norwegian researchers offered free contraception for one year to young women living in Tromso and Hamar in Norway, the abortion rate in those cities was cut in half. Could free contraception be an effective way to reduce abortion rates in other cities around the world?

     

    Norwegian Contraception Study

     

    The Norwegian project, which was conducted on behalf of the Directorate of Health and by SINTEF Technology and Society (The Foundation for Scientific and Industrial Research), included 3,500 women ages 20 to 24. This is the age group with the highest abortion rate in Norway. Four cities were included in the project: two where women received free contraception and two used for comparison. … It appears that offering free contraception to young women is an effective way to cut the abortion rate. In 2002, free hormone-based birth control was offered to Norwegian women ages 16 to 19, and abortion rates declined dramatically. When the one-year project was over, young women were offered reduced-rate contraception, and the number of abortions began to climb again.

     

    http://www.emaxhealth.com/1275/4/36034/free-contraception-can-cut-abortion-rate-half.html

    Now there’s a common ground solution everyone should be sure to support.

  • ddevonb

    “Frankly, I think anyone who believes that a fertilized egg is a “person” should take a moment and ask a couple who have undergone a failed IVF attempt how they enjoy being parents.  That should make it very clear that pregnancy does not begin at fertilization.”

     

    There is no logic in your statement. If a couple just had a failed IVF attempt, that would mean that that the unborn child or children died… so this couple would likely be very sad.

    The proposed amendment says that we honor personhood from the beginning of biological development. The beginning of life is the beginning of biological development. This is a scientific fact. The beginning is the beginning. Not a hard concept to understand.