• womantrust

    Womantrust Thanks Kirsten for a very informative and timely piece- and what an eye opener and outrage! That a third world developing country is way ahead of the U.S. where we’re supposed to be leaders of the industrialized world. Has the U. S. also signed international agreements on womens health and rights? If so, that may be a way to block the stupid Stupak move. To block public funding for one of the most common legal medical procedures for women because a gang of bullying men in skirts (the RCC council of bishops), don’t like it is absurd and if made into law, certainly violates the separation of church and state- by mandating by law what is the religious belief of the minority. As to our lawmakers- how would they like it if they or a loved one had a pregnancy that jeapordized their health or was inconsistent with life and their insurance wouldn’t cover that procedure- as it does now? If this becomes law, it may in fact collide with rights protected by law in Roe- making a conflict of competing laws. If the RCC is successful in this move, we can expect to see comprehensive sex education, contraceptive care and sterilizations also outlawed. Thanks again for an excellent article that really shines the light on our fumbling, stumbling Congress and please keep writing.

  • al4gzuz2

    Kerstin, I have lived in Ethiopia for a month and have certainly experienced the extreme difference of their culture from that of the United States. I find it interesting that you would choose a nation so completely opposite our own to hold up as a standard for what "ought to be" in the US. You mention in your article that these women did not even understand that intercourse would lead to pregnancy. Conversely, in the US we have a high rate of literacy and education (approx. 35.5% in Ethiopia as compared with 99% in the US). When I was in Ethiopia, education was often spoken of as a hope and dream among the people I met and spoke with, and they held the US up as their standard. I find it somewhat of a reversal to then exhibit their povery and harsh living conditions as an exemplar situation for health care in our nation. Also, there are so many issues within Ethiopian culture that effect a scenario such as this- religious sterilization, for one, happens frequently, and this procedure has been the cause of disease and death for women. I enjoy Reality Check for its attempts at getting to the truth of a matter, but this seems silly to me. A country that is so clearly underdeveloped and (to be brutally honest) who should be using what health care resources they have for malaria treatment and not abortions, should not be the United States’ "ideal".

  • kirsten-sherk

    The point is not that Ethiopia is the gold standard for health-care,
    but that other countries craft their health care policies with a mind
    of what’s best for health outcomes, not the particular religious
    beliefs of a handful of legislators.

     

    I think it’s important that we not pit one health priority against
    another, but take a more holistic approach. This means not ignoring
    abortion when it is a major cause of maternal mortality, but increasing
    access to safe abortion care AND preventing unwanted or unsafe
    pregnancies. If you watch Not Yet Rain (which you can do online at
    http://www.notyetrain.org), I think you’ll see that we consider basic
    education crucial to the whole process. 

     

    Ethiopia is just one example of a country that understood that increasing access to safe abortion care would reduce matenral mortality. South Africa is another; it explicitly included legal abortion in its 1994 constitution, among other health and welfare priorities. In the 15 years since, abortion-related mortality has decreased 91%. 

  • progo35

    Then go live in Ethiopia.

    "Well behaved women seldom make history."-Laurel Thatcher Ulrich

Mobile Theme