New York State Senators Defect to Republican Party; Reproductive Health, Marriage Equality Legislation Doomed

Both reproductive health and same-sex marriage advocates’ hopes were riding high on the conclusion of the New York state legislative session.  Reproductive health advocates have been building support across the state for the Reproductive Health Act — a bill to codify Roe in state law — since the beginning of the session. Advocates had hoped for swift passage of the bill in the waning days of the session.  Same-sex marriage proponents, too, were engaging in an all-out push, lobbying and asking New Yorkers to pressure their representatives. Both groups hoped that a Democratic Senate — the first in 40 years — could pass socially progressive legislation that the Republican Senate had blocked for decades.

But now Senate Democrats Hiram Monserrate and Pedro Espada Jr. are joining Senate Republicans in a motion to replace Majority Leader Malcolm Smith with Republican, robbing the Democrats of a majority in the legislative body.

The New York Times reports,

All 30 Republicans stood with their hands raised, signaling a vote for a change in leadership. Mr. Espada and Mr. Monserrate joined them, each raising his hand. It appeared that Republicans had won the vote by a 32-to-30 margin. If the Republicans retake the chamber, Dean G. Skelos, of Long Island, would likely be the new majority leader. 

Senate watchers speculate that Monserrate’s and Espada’s intense opposition to same-sex marriage led them to defect from the Party. "Why Mr. Espada and Mr. Monserrate suddenly defected on Monday afternoon was not immediately clear. Both men are under investigation by the authorities. The state attorney general’s office is investigating a health care agency, Soundview HealthCare Network, that Mr. Espada ran until recently. And Mr. Monserrate, who was indicted on felony assault charges in March stemming from an attack on his companion, would automatically be thrown out of office if convicted," The Times reports.

Meanwhile, Malcolm Smith called the move "illegal."

Blogger Elizabeth Benjamin concludes, "At this point, it’s all kind of a mess."

Like this story? Your $10 tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

For more information or to schedule an interview with contact

  • invalid-0

    actually, espada is pro-marriage equality and monserrate is “undecided” (or so he says). my reading of this is this is only about power. about politics…

  • invalid-0

    The Insurgents were great Democrats on Monday morning, in the evening they are potential crimials who judgement is in question. Can Malcom spell hypocrite or does Hank have to tell him how?

  • abbylevon

    Every one deserves to be happy and one may only be truly happy if he or she is treated fairly is not deprived of certain privileges as well as one’s sense of importance to the society. CreditCardsClub.Com

  • invalid-0

    It really comes down to what is best for the people. Not everyone is created equal, thus we a think differntly (thank goodness!). It would be good for the govt folks we have elected to office to pay more attention to what the peoole are asking and place their votes in that direction instead of their personal agendas.

  • invalid-0

    This is only about power & politics. The politics only thing on them selves letting the people alone if there is not money… Only the people with money have rights over the eyes of politics.

  • invalid-0

    yeah Every one deserves to be happy and one may only be truly happy if he or she is treated fairly is not deprived of certain privileges. absolutely right