Montana “Egg As Person” Initiative Signature Count Falls Short


Colorado’s egg-as-person ballot initiative has succeeded, meaning that in November Colorado residents will be casting votes on when life begins. But opponents of a similar initiative in Montana say that, according to their research, supporters have failed to gather enough signatures to put the measure on the ballot, the Missoulan reports.

The initiative, known as Constitutional Initiative 100, or CI-100, would define life as beginning at "conception" — a medically ambiguous moment distinct from implantation, which is defined as the moment when pregnancy begins. Groups organizing for CI-100 needed 44,000 signatures from Montana residents to put the initiative on the ballot, and opponents say supporters have collected less than 22,000. Twenty-five groups, including abortion rights and human rights organizations, came together to oppose the bill, which could, like its counterpart in Colorado, criminalize certain forms of hormonal contraception as well as stem cell research and in-vitro fertilization, and abortion. The Missoulan writes,

[Opponents of the measure] argued that CI-100 would have done
more than issue a complete ban on abortion. It also would have banned
certain kinds of birth control, like the IUD, which work by preventing
a fertilized egg from implanting on the uterine wall. They said it
could have opened up women who suffer miscarriages to investigations
and complicated health care for all women of child-bearing age.

The Missoulan also notes that the state’s Catholic bishops never backed the measure. Nor did Montana Right to Life. As Dana Goldstein wrote when she covered this initiative in May,

Montana’s bishops explained their rationale as such: "Legal experts
agree that the current Supreme Court would, at best, decline to hear
the case, and at worst, use the opportunity to reaffirm the right to
abortion yet another time. The more times the Supreme Court’s abortion
decisions are affirmed, the more difficult it becomes to obtain further
hearings from the Court and to expect decisions to end abortion."

Like this story? Your $10 tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

  • invalid-0

    If cooler heads and reason have triumphed over anti-abortion hysteria in Montana, does that mean the momentum for the stupid “egg as person” movement has stalled for good?

  • invalid-0

    in Colorado. But it’s hard to imagine that with even the mainstream anti-choice organizations opposed to this absurd initiative, it will prevail.

    Amie Newman

    Managing Editor, RH Reality Check